Sustainable Youth Ministry 3
I was sent a link to an article this week that just appeared in Christianity Today – it is by Kara Powell and it asks the question: “Is the day of age segregated ministry over?” You can read it at: http://tr.im/A5OF
This is certainly not a new debate in youth ministry and this won’t be the end of it either. While everyone has their own opinion, just this morning I launched into Chapter 11 of the book by Mark DeVries, Sustainable Youth Ministry, which I now consider to be the most significant book on youth ministry released in the past 5 years at least. I came across some interesting insights that are well worth sharing.
Mark’s previous book was Family Based Youth Ministry. In that book he made a compelling argument for ministry that is congregation or family based. Now, based on new research, he is saying: “Um! Hold on just a minute – here are some new insights that need to be considered.” And he proceeds to focus on the importance of peer-based ministry. See the extract below.
Now, in no way is he suggesting that adults and church involvement is unimportant – in fact, he is raising the bar considerably on that front (with ideas like: (1) we don’t just need one leader involved in the life of each teenager, but each student needs multiple godly adults involved in their lives; and (2) the youth pastor should be primarily the architect of a constellation of relationships!) – but it is pushing the debate back towards a more inclusive approach that looks at youth ministry as a vital part of the church, led by adult leaders with significant adult involvement, yet with space for age specific connections where teens get to be with their peers and trained to minister as leader themselves.
Here is the extract from chapter 11 of Mark’s book:
THE COOL CHURCH
Because of my strong emphasis on family-based youth ministry over the past fifteen years or so, I’ve argued passionately that what kids need most is not just a group of Christian peers but also droves of durable, Christian adults. But I’m starting to broaden my appreciation for the unique role the youth themselves can play.
No one brought this principle home to me as clearly as Rick Lawrence did in Group Magazine’s fascinating study of ten thousand youth group kids. They asked students, “If you were choosing a church, how important would the following things be?” Check out the first two responses, both of which ranked way above all the others (numbers represent the percentage of kids who rated this item as “very important”):
1. a welcoming environment where I can be myself: 73 percent
2. quality relationships with teenagers: 70 percent
When kids are thinking about the church they might want to be a part of, they’re not-at least not initially-thinking about the adult leaders. They’re asking, “Are these the kind of people I would like to be friends with?” Interestingly, the third-highest response, coming in at 59 percent, was “a senior pastor who understands and loves teenagers.” Coming in near the bottom of the list was “quality relationships with adults” (only 36 percent). And bringing up the rear with only 21 percent was “a fast-paced, high-tech, entertaining ministry approach.”
The article that reported this study, incidentally, was called “The Cool Church.” If we were to borrow Catie’s language, this would not be a church that looks cool to everyone who comes, but rather a church in which “I feel cool enough” to belong.
Please understand. Youth not ranking “relationships with adults” high on the list does not minimize the profound role adults play. Long-term, sustainable faith is most deeply influenced by the adults that surround our kids, not just their peers. But as we look at what causes kids to stay in groups, peers playa central role, a role that most adults simply can’t play.
As I look back on my experience as the new kid at church, the results of this study ring true. At eleven years old, I moved to Texas with my mom, and we quickly found Central Presbyterian Church in downtown Waco. The service was predictable enough, the adults were nice enough, but when it came time for “fellowship hour,” I wanted to throw up.
As my mother “fellowshiped” with all the other fellowshipers, I was left to stand in my prepubescent body by the ten-cent Coke machine. Kids of all ages with dimes in hand walked past me to the Coke machine, gathered their bargain prize and walked away. Though a few gave a polite hello, most were just as uncomfortable having a new kid around as I was standing there.
It wasn’t until Thereasa, an angelic tenth-grader, introduced herself to me that my terror started to thaw, and I began to think there might be a chance I would find a place. Every time she invited me to sit next to her, it was an affirmation that I had a place, that 1 really was starting to belong.
Thereasa did what the adults in the group couldn’t have done. She made me feel like part of the group. It’s not that adults were insignificant (they became more important as time went on), but adults could not be the sticky paper that kept me connected to the church. Friends had to be.
Once I began to grasp the power of these principles a few years ago, our youth ministry team decided we wanted to make our group the safest, most welcoming place in the city for teenagers, a place where no one could ever walk away saying “I could never be cool enough” to fit in there.